Renewal
.:Member Reviews:.
  FOreseer
Played for less than 1 month 2008-01-14
Overall, this is a wonderful server. Great party system makes playing a lot of fun, the community rocks out, and was really welcoming, and you can dive right into the action. Only problem is the economy isn't great (as their's a fairly complete mall), but the mall is expensive, so the economy exists off of discounted items.
Rating: 82
Comment #1
Server
Stability: 10
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 10
Eventfulness: 7
Game Masters
Friendliness: 8
Availability: 7
Helpfulness: 10
Game-play
Economy: 5
Guild Competition: 5
Class Balance: 10

  FOreseer
Played for 2 months 2008-01-05
Depressingly bad. One of the GM's told me to lick my -rude word for vaginal fluids- off of the -curse word-ing ground when I asked him a question. When I told him to -curse word- off, he muted me for 48 hours, and jailed me for 24.
Rating: 48
Comment #2
Server
Stability: 6
Availability: 9
Community
Friendliness: 7
Eventfulness: 1
Game Masters
Friendliness: 1
Availability: 4
Helpfulness: 1
Game-play
Economy: 6
Guild Competition: 7
Class Balance: 6

  FOreseer
Played for less than 1 month 2008-01-05
Good server - I love the community. The GM's are fun (and let me make fun of their manskirts <_<), and active. They aren't very good with technical support, but they know their ingame stuff stat. PvP intensive like any sHR. Has lots of small guilds for WoE. No economy, as mall sells basically everything.
Rating: 75
Comment #3
Server
Stability: 7
Availability: 9
Community
Friendliness: 10
Eventfulness: 7
Game Masters
Friendliness: 9
Availability: 7
Helpfulness: 7
Game-play
Economy: 1
Guild Competition: 10
Class Balance: 8

  FOreseer
Played for more than 1 year 2008-01-05
-Sigh- Used to be a good server. It sucks now... the community used to be great, but all the nice people left after the GM's became corrupt.
Rating: 48
Comment #4
Server
Stability: 10
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 3
Eventfulness: 1
Game Masters
Friendliness: 3
Availability: 3
Helpfulness: 1
Game-play
Economy: 5
Guild Competition: 3
Class Balance: 9

  FOreseer
Played for 12 months 2008-01-05
Awesome server. I'm dead serious -- if you're going to play a LR, play this one. The thing about it is the only time I've ever had serious lag was for about five minutes when the server went down for maintenance, but the GM's got it up really fast. Community is cool, and inviting. The GM's are available and help with problems!
Rating: 89
Comment #5
Server
Stability: 9
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 8
Eventfulness: 6
Game Masters
Friendliness: 8
Availability: 10
Helpfulness: 10
Game-play
Economy: 10
Guild Competition: 10
Class Balance: 8

  FOreseer
Played for 5 months 2008-01-05
If you're looking for a free alternative to RO that is very much like the official servers, this is the one to goto, except for the fact that the community is much, much nicer, and the GM's more active and able to help. Great WoE! Not too many powerhouse guilds.
Rating: 88
Comment #6
Server
Stability: 10
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 10
Eventfulness: 9
Game Masters
Friendliness: 8
Availability: 9
Helpfulness: 6
Game-play
Economy: 9
Guild Competition: 7
Class Balance: 10

  FOreseer
Played for less than 1 month 2008-01-05
The problem with leveling here is that you can only gain one level at a time. This completely eliminates the urge to go MVP a really strong monster in a day and gain, say, 30 levels from it. However, the community is really nice, GM's are nice and helpful, but they aren't on enough. Seriously. :x
Rating: 83
Comment #7
Server
Stability: 10
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 10
Eventfulness: 10
Game Masters
Friendliness: 8
Availability: 3
Helpfulness: 10
Game-play
Economy: 8
Guild Competition: 5
Class Balance: 9

  FOreseer
Played for 1 month 2008-01-27
Meh... Server lags a lot, but it's usually on. A few corrupt GM's will ban you if you criticize/suggest things to them. Meh.
Rating: 45
Comment #8
Server
Stability: 4
Availability: 9
Community
Friendliness: 4
Eventfulness: 1
Game Masters
Friendliness: 4
Availability: 8
Helpfulness: 3
Game-play
Economy: 3
Guild Competition: 7
Class Balance: 2
Owner's reply to this review:
2008-01-28
Lag? I think 99.9% of ScytheRO players will disagree. It could be your computer, there's an F.A.Q. about it if you're the only one lagging. GM's corrupt? How...? I doubt you were banned for what you say, but you can appeal on the forums.

  FOreseer
Played for less than 1 month 2008-01-27
This is the worst server I've ever played on. I got @dropall'd by a corrupt GM (who is the main GM's boyfriend), then was muted for 20. When that wore off, he did so much stuff, it was worse than Niktout. He's awful. Heh... Server is kind of stable, though... Community isn't bad either... But Hatii makes it bad.
Rating: 41
Comment #9
Server
Stability: 7
Availability: 7
Community
Friendliness: 6
Eventfulness: 4
Game Masters
Friendliness: 1
Availability: 9
Helpfulness: 1
Game-play
Economy: 1
Guild Competition: 1
Class Balance: 4
Owner's reply to this review:
2008-01-27
I'm sorry that GarmRO wasn't the right server for you and I hope you eventually find one you like. I know for a fact that you were never @dropall'd as I checked command logs and more. Even if you were, you would still NEED to provide proof!

  FOreseer
Played for less than 1 month 2008-02-22
Can't stand the server. People aren't intelligent - When I asked an admin about an SP Regen item seller, he told me to go get a pet and have it attack for me. When I told him that what he said was irrelevant he got angry and kicked me. <.< No one online, it's all just merchant stalls.
Rating: 35
Comment #10
Server
Stability: 6
Availability: 6
Community
Friendliness: 1
Eventfulness: 1
Game Masters
Friendliness: 1
Availability: 5
Helpfulness: 1
Game-play
Economy: 7
Guild Competition: 1
Class Balance: 6
Owner's reply to this review:
2008-03-05
Perhaps this player is mistaken. He asked one person a question and believed the server to be below his standards. His report was based on 1 day of play. Obviously he visited when the player count was low. The only recent kick was a hacker.

  FOreseer
Played for 1 month 2008-02-25
Okay server, huge community making WoE super fun. Only 3 guilds able to compete in WoE, small guilds get raped; even merged ones. Server lags a lot, crashes 1 - 2 times a day, will be down for a few hours once every few weeks. Ranged chars super nerfed, they do -50% damage in PvP. GM's are great, very responsive, nice, activ
Rating: 79
Comment #11
Server
Stability: 5
Availability: 8
Community
Friendliness: 8
Eventfulness: 5
Game Masters
Friendliness: 10
Availability: 10
Helpfulness: 10
Game-play
Economy: 10
Guild Competition: 5
Class Balance: 8

  FOreseer
Played for 6 months 2008-02-27
The server is just kind of... Bleh. I didn't like it. Hostile community (espescially in PvP), lots of bad-mouthing other people, lots of eDrama (you might like this server if you like to follow that kind of thing... LOTS of it), Earns points for good donation system, and no over powered customs. GM's ---> </3.
Rating: 36
Comment #12
Server
Stability: 3
Availability: 7
Community
Friendliness: 3
Eventfulness: 6
Game Masters
Friendliness: 1
Availability: 8
Helpfulness: 3
Game-play
Economy: 1
Guild Competition: 1
Class Balance: 3

  FOreseer
Played for less than 1 month 2008-02-27
<.< I find it weird how the server is less than a year old, yet people claim to have been playing for a year (+)... GM's, maybe? I found a server that was tarnished, corrupt with hacked items (o_o Angra?), and completely stupid in every way possible. GM's unfriendly, economy in the dirt because GM's give items to their friends.
Rating: 24
Comment #13
Server
Stability: 4
Availability: 3
Community
Friendliness: 4
Eventfulness: 3
Game Masters
Friendliness: 3
Availability: 2
Helpfulness: 2
Game-play
Economy: 1
Guild Competition: 1
Class Balance: 1

  FOreseer
Played for 1 month 2008-03-31
Very good server. Server is not laggy at all, and has never been down during the time I was on the server; English side of the community is nice, however there are a lot of alternate languages spoken; GM's are great, but aren't on much; Events are planned fairly well; Economy is good, as is guild comptition and balalnce. New!
Rating: 89
Comment #14
Server
Stability: 10
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 7
Eventfulness: 10
Game Masters
Friendliness: 10
Availability: 4
Helpfulness: 10
Game-play
Economy: 8
Guild Competition: 10
Class Balance: 10

  FOreseer
Played for less than 1 month 2009-11-28
Server is always online but always lags. Community is very friendly. AUTOMATED events are every day, they are dull and mundane, however, as they involve clicking an NPC at the right time. Economy is weak, but that is due to a low player base (of around 30). One guild owns every castle in Prontera (Legend). They're very nice, as I said before, but there is still no competition. Statistically there are over 20x the number of snipers than clowns. It's to be expected, but not to that extremity.
Rating: 51
Comment #15
Server
Stability: 3
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 10
Eventfulness: 5
Game Masters
Friendliness: 7
Availability: 10
Helpfulness: 1
Game-play
Economy: 3
Guild Competition: 1
Class Balance: 1
Owner's reply to this review:
2009-11-29
There is no lag on the server, it's your crappy connection. Yes, a lot of the event's are automated, so everyone get's a chance to play and win, but they are 90% ran by GM's not on timers. Yes, our player base is low, we need more players to improve our Economy and Guild Competition, it's impossible to improve those without players. We open 1 castle only per WoE, so saying that 1 guild dominates is an overstatement, but with a low population can you expect anything less?

  FOreseer
Played for 1 month 2009-08-22
The server has some lag issues, but is always online. Community (when not AFK) is very nice. Events are daily, but they're usually the same scripted events (hence 7 and not 10). GM's are nice, but not there. Not very helpful either, but they're very nice and patient. Sadly, the economy is in tatters. No one B>/S>/T>'s, there are almost no forgers or alchs, etc. If you're looking for a war server, this isn't it. No guild competition at all. Excellent class diversity. Overall score: 7.5/10
Rating: 66
Comment #16
Server
Stability: 3
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 10
Eventfulness: 7
Game Masters
Friendliness: 10
Availability: 6
Helpfulness: 6
Game-play
Economy: 3
Guild Competition: 1
Class Balance: 10

  FOreseer
Played for 4 months 2010-03-25
Very good server. GM's are excellent. @main allows for easy party creation. Lots of small guilds. Economy isn't doing so well atm, but that's just due to slightly dead population, so drops and stuff can be kind of hard to buy but it's really not a big problem and it's getting better. Once WoE really kicks off, server will be real solid.
Rating: 94
Comment #17
Server
Stability: 10
Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 10
Eventfulness: 10
Game Masters
Friendliness: 10
Availability: 10
Helpfulness: 10
Game-play
Economy: 7
Guild Competition: 9
Class Balance: 8

back to top